9533 Tall Grass Trail — St. John, IN 46373
Active
▼ $34,995
St. John, IN 46373

9533 Tall Grass Trail

$1,115,000
5 beds · 5 baths · 6,929 sqft
$34,995 below original 95 days on market $5,436/yr taxes
01About this home

HUGE PRICE REDUCTION! Luxury living with nearly 7,000 square feet of open floor plan design! This magnificent home features 8' double entry doors, beautiful hardwood flooring, 8' interior doors, custom blinds and custom primary closets. Top of the line Anderson 400 Series windows throughout this stunning 6-bedroom, 5-bathroom home. It features a designer kitchen with an 8' island, walk-in butler's pantry, high end appliances that include a commercial grade refrigerator. There's a formal dining room that extends to an informal sitting room where family and friends can enjoy good conversation or just a quiet place for reading a good book. Dedicated office space with 8' glass double doors and a formal living room that includes a gas fireplace! A sliding patio door off the breakfast nook takes you to the screened in patio. Full laundry and mud room complete with a sink, abundance of storage and counter space. The beautiful crossover staircase from the kitchen to foyer will take you to a primary suite that includes a spa-like bath, separate shower, and a massive custom walk-in closet! Bedroom 2 has its own ensuite, Bedrooms 3 and 4 share a Jack and Jill bath, and what was once used for a massive playroom, is Bedroom 5 spanning 22' x 19'! Venture downstairs to the finished basement that was completed by the same builder. Beautiful vinyl plank flooring, a 160-bottle wine refrigerator, undercounter beverage refrigerator, TV, and mats for the workout room! The basement includes a full bathroom, Bedroom 6 and if you don't need the workout room, just remove the mats for Bedroom 7! Plenty of space for a pool table or turn it into a theater room! The 3-car garage has a wall of cabinets to keep your space organized! There was also a water softening system installed valued at over 5,100. There were over 131,000 in upgrades after the purchase of this home that was meant to be a forever home, so everything completed was done intentionally to be forever and long lasting! Don't miss out!

02Inside the home
03By the numbers
$1,115,000
List price
6,929
Square feet
5
Bedrooms
4 full / 1 half
Bathrooms
2024
Year built
0.33 ac
Lot size
3
Garage spaces
$5,436
Annual taxes
Detached Single
Style
95
Days on market
04Open houses
Saturday
Jun 13
4pm–6pm
Sunday
Jun 14
4pm–8pm
05Features
Heating
Natural Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Appliances
Double OvenMicrowaveDishwasherHigh End RefrigeratorBar FridgeWasherDryerStainless Steel Appliance(s)Wine RefrigeratorRange HoodWater Softener Owned
Parking
Garage Door OpenerHeated GarageAttachedGarage
Construction
BrickWood Siding
Sewer
Public Sewer
06Neighborhood
  • McDonald's 1.3 mi
  • Culver's 1.3 mi
  • Speedway 1.4 mi
  • Aldi 1.4 mi
  • Always Open 1.5 mi
  • James E. Larimer Park 0.4 mi
  • Schillton Hills Park 0.8 mi
  • Prairie West Park 0.9 mi
  • Louis Estates Park 0.9 mi
  • Edgewood Estates Park 1.0 mi
  • Homestead Acres Park Number 2 1.0 mi
  • Nothing surfaced nearby in our maps data.
POI data via Mapbox · OpenStreetMap contributors
07History

Every event we have for this address, straight from the MLS.

Jun 11, 2026
Price reducedThis listing
McColly Real Estate
$1,115,000
−$34,995
Mar 8, 2026
Listed for saleThis listing
McColly Real Estate
$1,149,995
Sourced from MRED. Older events appear here as our history backfill completes.
08Ask Dwello

Real answers about this home — pricing, schools, what to ask, anything.

09See it for yourself

Stand in the kitchen.
See the light at 4pm.

Photos can only do so much. Pick a time — we'll meet you at the door.

Connect with Ewelina, Anna, or Nadeem — real people on our team, no call centers.
10Similar homes
Listed by McColly Real Estate · Kathy Whaley
MLS data provided through MLS GRID · MRED MLS · MLS# MRD12586287
Talk to an agent