Hancock County · Illinois

Homes for sale in Carthage.

There are 11 homes for sale in Carthage right now, with a median list price of $28,900. Every active listing below updates live from the MLS.

11
homes for sale
$29K
median list price
$93
median price / sq ft
386 days
avg. days on market
How the Carthage market is moving.
Closed MLS sales — last 12 months.
June 2025: 55July 2025: 11August 2025: 11September 2025: 44October 2025: 11November 2025: 33December 2025: 22January 2026: 33February 2026: 22March 2026: 22April 2026: 44May 2026: 11JunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMay
June 2025: $140K$140KJuly 2025: $148K$148KAugust 2025: $73K$73KSeptember 2025: $93K$93KOctober 2025: $145K$145KNovember 2025: $185K$185KDecember 2025: $118K$118KJanuary 2026: $105K$105KFebruary 2026: $195K$195KMarch 2026: $119K$119KApril 2026: $117K$117KMay 2026: $99K$99KJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMay
June 2025: 75d75dJuly 2025: 71d71dAugust 2025: 113d113dSeptember 2025: 172d172dOctober 2025: 164d164dNovember 2025: 183d183dDecember 2025: 248d248dJanuary 2026: 216d216dFebruary 2026: 147d147dMarch 2026: 214d214dApril 2026: 157d157dMay 2026: 34d34dJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMay
29 homes closed in Carthage over the last 12 months. Updated continuously from the MLS.

Active listings in Carthage.

See all 11 homes →

About the Carthage market.

Carthage is one of the communities dwello Home Group covers across Hancock County and the broader Chicago and Northwest Indiana market. The listings on this page are pulled live from the MLS and refreshed continuously, so what you see is what's genuinely available right now.

Whether you're buying your first home, moving up, or selling, a local dwello agent can give you a real read on Carthage — pricing, neighborhoods, schools, and how fast homes are actually moving. Reach out any time; there's no pressure and no obligation.

Browse Carthage by property type.

Nearby areas.

Carthage real estate questions.

How many homes are for sale in Carthage, IL?
As of May 2026, there are 11 active listings in Carthage, Illinois, plus 2 more under contract. The listings on this page update straight from the MLS, so they reflect current inventory.
What is the median home price in Carthage?
The median list price of active homes in Carthage is currently $28,900, or roughly $93 per square foot. Prices vary widely by neighborhood, size, and condition — browse the active listings above for live pricing.
Does dwello Home Group serve Carthage?
Yes. dwello Home Group is based in Chicago's south suburbs and Northwest Indiana and works with buyers and sellers across the wider region, including Carthage. Get in touch and we'll connect you with the right agent.
How fast do homes sell in Carthage?
Active listings in Carthage have been on the market an average of 386 days. 9 homes have closed there in the last 90 days. Well-priced homes in good condition tend to move noticeably faster than average.
How do I schedule a showing in Carthage?
Open any listing on this page and use the "Schedule a showing" button, or contact dwello Home Group directly. A local agent will set up the tour and walk you through every step — financing, offers, inspections, and closing.

Thinking about Carthage?

Tour a home, get a straight answer on pricing, or just ask a question. A local dwello agent is ready when you are.