Illinois vs. Indiana: what changes when you buy across the state line
Property taxes, income tax, attorneys, and closing costs all work differently a few miles apart. Here is what actually changes between the south suburbs and Northwest Indiana, with real numbers.

From Homer Glen or Tinley Park, the Indiana line is a short drive. Plenty of buyers look at both sides, and the homes can look similar. The costs around them don't. Property taxes, income tax, who handles your closing, and what you pay at the table all change at the state line. Here's what's different, what isn't, and how to compare two specific homes fairly.
Property taxes are the biggest difference
Indiana caps the property tax bill on a home you live in at 1% of its assessed value. Illinois has no cap like that. That single rule is why the same-priced house usually carries a much smaller tax bill in Indiana.
Some real numbers. Across about 4,300 single-family homes sold in eight southwest suburbs over the two years ending October 2026 (Homer Glen, Lockport, New Lenox, Mokena, Frankfort, Orland Park, Tinley Park, and Lemont), the yearly tax bill ran about 1.9% of the sale price, with most homes between 1.6% and 2.2%. On a $450,000 home that's roughly $8,700 a year. An Indiana homestead assessed at $450,000 is capped at about $4,500.
Two cautions. The Indiana cap applies to the assessed value, which isn't always the price you paid, and voter-approved levies can sit on top of it, so a bill can land a little above 1%. And the cap only applies once you've filed for the homestead deduction. It isn't automatic. Title companies commonly file it at closing, so ask.
Both states bill property tax in arrears, a year behind, in two installments. Our property taxes guide covers how the Illinois side is calculated and which exemptions to claim.
Income tax depends on where you live and where you work
Illinois has a flat state income tax of 4.95%. Indiana's state rate is 2.95% for 2026, but every Indiana county adds its own. Lake County's is 1.5%, so a Lake County resident pays 4.45% combined. That's lower than Illinois, though closer than the state rates alone suggest.
The part people miss: Illinois and Indiana have no reciprocal tax agreement. If you live in Indiana and work in Illinois, Illinois taxes those wages, and you file in both states, with Indiana giving you a credit for the Illinois tax. How the county piece works out depends on your situation. Run it with a tax preparer before you count on the savings.
The contract and the closing work differently
In Illinois you'll have a real estate attorney. The standard contracts build in an attorney-review period, usually five business days, when either side's attorney can propose changes or cancel. The attorney also handles the title work and sits with you at closing.
Indiana doesn't work that way. There's no attorney-review period by default, the purchase agreement binds once both sides sign, and a title company runs the closing. You can still hire an attorney, and for anything unusual you should. But the safety net an Illinois buyer is used to isn't built in, so the inspection deadline and the other contingency dates in the contract matter more. Read them before you sign, not after.
Transfer taxes and closing costs
Illinois charges a transfer tax when a home sells: $1.50 per $1,000 of the price between the state and the county, usually paid by the seller, and some municipalities add their own on top. On a $450,000 sale the state and county portion is $675. Indiana has no real estate transfer tax.
On the buyer's side, the Illinois attorney is a cost Indiana buyers usually don't have, commonly $500 to $900. The rest is similar in both states: lender fees, the appraisal, title insurance, and prepaid taxes and insurance. Our budget guide walks through those line by line.
What stays the same
The loan doesn't care which state you pick. Rates, down payment rules, and how a lender qualifies you are the same on both sides. Inspections work the same way too, and both states require the seller to fill out a disclosure form.
One practical difference: a real estate license is issued state by state. An agent has to be licensed in Indiana to represent you there. Ewelina Siuta, dwello's founder, is licensed in both. The listings also live in different systems. The homes on this site come from the Chicago-area MLS, which carries only a small number of Indiana properties, so for Northwest Indiana ask an agent to set up a search from the local MLS.
So is Indiana cheaper?
Usually on taxes, yes. Property tax is the largest gap, and for most buyers it's the one that decides it. Income tax narrows once you add the county rate, and it can disappear if you keep working in Illinois. Sales tax is close: Indiana charges 7% statewide, and Illinois charges 6.25% plus local taxes that vary by town.
What taxes don't tell you is how the two homes compare. A lower tax bill on a house that's farther from work, or that needs more work, isn't automatically the better deal. Compare the full monthly cost of each home, not the states.
How to compare two specific homes
Do this with real listings, not averages.
- Take the actual tax bill from each listing and divide by 12.
- Add the mortgage payment, homeowner's insurance, and any HOA fee.
- Add what the commute costs you in time and tolls.
- If you'll live in one state and work in the other, have a tax preparer estimate your income tax both ways.
A dwello agent can pull the tax history and recent sales for any home you're weighing, on either side of the line, so you're comparing the numbers that will actually show up on your statement. No obligation.