3464 Old Mill Road — Highland Park, IL 60035
Active
Highland Park, IL 60035

3464 Old Mill Road

$1,575,000
5 beds · 6 baths · 5,819 sqft
Listed at $1,575,000 7 days on market $31,917/yr taxes
01About this home

Expanded and renovated in 2008, this two-story prairie-style executive home offers over 9,000 square feet of finished living area across three levels, all easily accessible by a centrally located elevator or stairs, and is situated on over an acre of wooded property along a quiet, private road in Highland Park. The home offers exceptional flexibility with spaces ideal for a variety of lifestyles, hobbies, and extended living arrangements. The home is perfectly centered on over an acre of fully landscaped property with old-growth oak, pine, maple, and a variety of other trees with an endless supply of firewood for the three wood-burning fireplaces with gas starters. The main floor has 10-foot ceilings and was designed for one-floor living. It features a large primary bedroom opening up to a south-facing tropical solarium, a huge walk-in closet, large primary bath with dual sinks, over 10 lineal feet of deep mirrored medicine cabinets, Infinity soaking tub, oversized walk-in shower, and a separate toilet and bidet room. The extra-large kitchen features custom teak cabinetry with full-depth pot drawers, deep upper cabinets, granite tops, and a 6-burner Thermador commercial gas range with griddle, warming trays, and full-size lighted range hood. The kitchen also features a large food-preparation island with granite top, under-counter refrigerator, wine cooler, beverage center, and l teak base cabinets. A second island has counter seating for ten. A large walk-in pantry and a second full kitchen are seamlessly connected to the main kitchen, facilitating large gatherings and specialty cooking. The kitchen and dining area open up onto a large outside concrete deck for outside dining and evening fires overlooking the oversized back yard. The second floor features 9 foot ceilings, a large office and living, study, or hobby area, an ensuite guest room with outside patio, a second guest bedroom with shared bath that has a jacuzzi tub, a large potential second primary suite with an outside patio, a bonus room that is pre-plumbed for an additional bathroom, and an additional bedroom. The expanded lower-level features 8' 6" ceilings, a large, mirrored gym with oak flooring on sleepers, an adjoining full bath and steam room, a separate movie room, and a huge storage area with heavy-duty shelving units. The infrastructure includes 400-amp electrical service, a new 6-inch sewer line, copper water service, three dual sump pumps (120v and 12v with battery backups). The property also features a separate 1,440 square foot fully finished building with 10-foot ceilings, 8-foot-high double garage door with two parking spaces, a 12x22 shop space, three 8x12 storage rooms, and a 360 square foot studio apartment. The home features convenient commuting, with access to US Route 41, the Fort Sheridan Metra line, restaurants, shopping, and community events of Highland Park and Highwood. A truly unique home offering privacy, scale, and thoughtful design in a prime Highland Park location.

02Inside the home
03By the numbers
$1,575,000
List price
5,819
Square feet
5
Bedrooms
5 full / 1 half
Bathrooms
1953
Year built
1.15 ac
Lot size
4.5
Garage spaces
$31,917
Annual taxes
Prairie
Style
7
Days on market
04Features
Heating
Natural Gas
Cooling
Central AirZoned
Parking
GravelGarage Door OpenerGarageGarage OwnedAttachedDetached
Construction
StuccoStone
Sewer
Public Sewer
05Neighborhood
This home EElementary schoolMMiddle schoolHHigh school
E Elementary school
Wayne Thomas Elementary School
Highland Park, IL
📍1.1 mi🚗3 min🚶26 min
M Middle school
Northwood Junior High School
Highland Park, IL
📍32 mi🚗83 min
H High school
Highland Park High School
Highland Park, IL
📍2.4 mi🚗6 min🚶58 min
  • Koya 0.9 mi
  • McDonald's 1.1 mi
  • Taco Bell 1.2 mi
  • Wendy's 1.2 mi
  • Mobil Mart 1.0 mi
  • Casey's General Store 1.1 mi
  • Mobil Mart 1.2 mi
  • Mariano's Fresh Market 1.5 mi
  • Northcroft Park 0.4 mi
  • Danny Cunniff Park 0.4 mi
  • Old Elm Park 0.8 mi
  • Knoll Park 0.9 mi
  • Waveland Park 1.0 mi
  • Sheridan Park 1.0 mi
  • Starbucks 1.0 mi
POI data via Mapbox · OpenStreetMap contributors
06History

Every event we have for this address, straight from the MLS.

May 11, 2026
Listed for saleThis listing
Exit Strategy Realty
$1,575,000
Sourced from MRED. Older events appear here as our history backfill completes.
07Ask Dwello

Real answers about this home — pricing, schools, what to ask, anything.

08See it for yourself

Stand in the kitchen.
See the light at 4pm.

Photos can only do so much. Pick a time — we'll meet you at the door.

Connect with Ewelina, Anna, or Nadeem — real people on our team, no call centers.
09Similar homes
Listed by Exit Strategy Realty · Kelly Ipjian · 224-384-5224
MLS data provided through MLS GRID · MRED MLS · MLS# MRD12645085
Talk to an agent