1218 Sheridan Road — Evanston, IL 60202
Pending
Evanston, IL 60202

1218 Sheridan Road

$3,395,000
6 beds · 6 baths · 8,462 sqft
Listed at $3,395,000 14 days on market $40,205/yr taxes
01About this home

An extraordinary offering in Evanston's prestigious Lakeshore Historic District, this magnificent six-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bath Tudor Revival residence was masterfully designed by Ernest A. Mayo. A grand reception hall introduces the home, where sweeping Tudor-arched openings create a dramatic axial vista spanning the length of the main level, an architectural hallmark of Mayo & Mayo's celebrated "vista beyond" concept. The formal living room is nothing short of breathtaking, defined by richly beamed ceilings, a commanding fireplace clad in narrow Roman brick, and a striking south wall framed by a pointed arch with five exquisite leaded glass windows. Just beyond, a luminous enclosed sunroom offers walls of windows, built-in seating, and seamless access to the front terrace. To the west, a beautifully reimagined all-season porch by Morgante & Wilson features new flooring and a modern accordion glass door that opens to the exceptional rear grounds. The formal dining room is equally impressive, showcasing a second statement fireplace with tile surround, paneled walls, beamed ceilings, and custom geometric art glass windows that echo the home's refined design language. The recently updated chef's kitchen is both sophisticated and functional, centered around a marble island with seating and surrounded by custom white cabinetry, black marble countertops, and a bespoke Italian tile backsplash. High-end appliances, curated lighting, a fully outfitted walk-in pantry, and a discreet work/study nook complete this exceptional space. A serene sitting room tucked beneath the mezzanine level offers a quiet retreat, highlighted by designer hexagonal tile flooring and tranquil views of the lush backyard. The grand staircase, encased in rich oak paneling, ascends to a spectacular mezzanine library, where vaulted ceilings, slender wood beams, and walls of custom bookcases frame an elegant arched expanse of leaded glass windows and doors overlooking the grounds. The second level hosts a luxurious primary suite, featuring a spa-inspired bath with herringbone marble floors, dual pedestal sinks, a soaking tub, and an expansive glass-enclosed shower. The suite is further enhanced by a gas fireplace, abundant natural light, and a professionally designed walk-in closet. Additional accommodations include a guest suite with a spacious ensuite bath, as well as two generously sized bedrooms sharing a beautifully renovated bath. The third floor offers remarkable versatility with two additional bedrooms, two full baths, a whimsical oversized "sleepover" room, and an expansive game room, formerly a grand ballroom, perfect for entertaining on any scale. The lower level has been thoughtfully updated to include a bright laundry room, a fully equipped fitness studio with bamboo flooring, and an exceptional wine cellar and tasting room distinguished by stone walls, barrel-vaulted ceilings, and softly diffused natural light. Ample storage completes the level. Outdoors, the property is equally captivating. A stately natural stone walkway leads to a newly reconstructed brick front terrace spanning the width of the home. A brick driveway with an automatic gate provides access to a custom-designed 2.5-car garage by Morgante & Wilson, seamlessly integrated with the home's architectural character. The backyard is a private oasis designed for elevated entertaining, featuring a natural stone patio, a fully appointed outdoor kitchen with grill, pizza oven, and refrigeration, generous lounge areas, a hot tub, and professionally landscaped grounds with irrigation. Ideally situated just moments from Lake Michigan, this residence offers easy access to Dempster Street Beach, local boutiques, dining, and the "L," with downtown Chicago a convenient 25-30 minute drive. Impeccably maintained and thoughtfully enhanced, this distinguished home represents a rare opportunity to own a true architectural legacy.

02Inside the home
03By the numbers
$3,395,000
List price
8,462
Square feet
6
Bedrooms
5 full / 1 half
Bathrooms
1901
Year built
0.38 ac
Lot size
2
Garage spaces
$40,205
Annual taxes
Tudor
Style
14
Days on market
04Features
Heating
SteamRadiantRadiator(s)Radiant Floor
Cooling
Central AirSmall Duct High VelocityZoned
Appliances
RangeMicrowaveDishwasherRefrigeratorHigh End RefrigeratorFreezerWasherDryerDisposalStainless Steel Appliance(s)Wine RefrigeratorRange Hood
Parking
Brick DrivewaySide DrivewayGarage Door OpenerGarage OwnedDetachedGarage
Construction
Stucco
Sewer
Public Sewer
05Neighborhood
This home EElementary schoolMMiddle schoolHHigh school
E Elementary school
Dewey Elementary School
Evanston, IL
📍17 mi🚗44 min
M Middle school
Nichols Middle School
Evanston, IL
📍0.6 mi🚗2 min🚶14 min
H High school
Evanston Twp High School
Evanston, IL
📍1.6 mi🚗4 min🚶39 min
  • Evanston Grill 0.4 mi
  • Jimmy John's 0.4 mi
  • Union Pizza 0.4 mi
  • Siam Paragon 0.5 mi
  • Shinsen Evanston 0.5 mi
  • Oceanique 0.5 mi
  • Shell 0.4 mi
  • Trader Joe's 0.4 mi
  • Jewel-Osco 0.4 mi
  • Lucky Main Pantry 0.5 mi
  • Whole Foods Market 0.7 mi
  • 7-Eleven 0.8 mi
  • Stockham Place Park 400 ft
  • Burnham Shores Park 700 ft
  • Elliot Park 0.2 mi
  • Dawes Park 0.3 mi
  • Curry Park 0.4 mi
  • Patriots Park 0.4 mi
  • Blind Faith Cafe 0.4 mi
  • Evanston Pour 0.4 mi
  • The Brothers K Coffeehouse 0.5 mi
  • Piccolatté Cafè 0.6 mi
  • Cafecito 0.6 mi
  • Patisserie Coralie 0.6 mi
POI data via Mapbox · OpenStreetMap contributors
06History

Every event we have for this address, straight from the MLS.

May 15, 2026
PendingThis listing
$3,395,000
May 3, 2026
Listed for saleThis listing
Compass
$3,395,000
Sourced from MRED. Older events appear here as our history backfill completes.
07Ask Dwello

Real answers about this home — pricing, schools, what to ask, anything.

08See it for yourself

Stand in the kitchen.
See the light at 4pm.

Photos can only do so much. Pick a time — we'll meet you at the door.

Connect with Ewelina, Anna, or Nadeem — real people on our team, no call centers.
09Similar homes
Listed by Compass · Geoff Brown
MLS data provided through MLS GRID · MRED MLS · MLS# MRD12633803
Talk to an agent